IndianSubcontinent

Image copyrightGetty ImagesThree years ago, Ramachandra Guha, a historian and one of India's most respected public intellectuals, told an interviewer that India was "becoming a more intolerant country" than before.
A 50-year-old Muslim man had been killed in a mob lynching allegedly over rumours that his family had been storing and consuming beef at home.
A beef ban had been enforced by Narendra Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government.
Two leading and outspoken rationalists had recently been murdered elsewhere in the country."It is important to recognise that there was never a golden age in our history as an independent nation of complete tolerance or freedom of speech," Guha said.
"There have always been curbs and pusillanimity by politicians and governments.
But we are certainly becoming more intolerant, there is more violence."Now Guha himself has become a target of the intolerance he spoke about.
Barely a fortnight ago, he announced that he was joining an ambitious private non-profit university in the western city of Ahmedabad as a professor of humanities.
(Ahmedabad University's top leadership includes historian Patrick French, the biographer of Nobel Prize-winning writer VS Naipaul.) On Thursday, Guha tweeted that he would not join the new position due to "circumstances beyond his control".
He has not spoken about why he decided to change his mind.
College authorities have not yet responded to queries by journalists.
Not surprisingly, this outraged many: A senior journalist bemoaned the state of affairs when a celebrated intellectual could not teach in an institution of his choice:Guha responded cryptically, highlighting the irony of his situation:Now it appears that Guha was hounded out by the Hindu right wing in Gujarat, the home state of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and widely regarded as BJP's bailiwick.
A leader of the the student wing of the local BJP told the Indian Express newspaper that they had met an Ahmedabad University official and told him they didn't want Guha to teach in the city.
"We said we want intellectuals in our educational institutes and and not anti-nationals," he said, adding that they had quoted "anti-national content" from his books to the official.
Image copyrightGetty ImagesImage caption Guha's most recent work is a two-volume biography on Mahatma Gandhi The complaint said that Guha's writings "have encouraged divisive tendencies, alienation in the name of independence of the individual, freeing terrorists in the name of independence of the individual, and separating Jammu and Kashmir from the Indian union".They also referred to him as a Communist.
The complaints make it very clear that the students hadn't read Guha's work.Guha is an eclectic personality.
An economist by training, he has written acclaimed books on ecology, cricket, post-independence India and, most recently, an extraordinary two-volume biography of Mahatma Gandhi.
He has taught at Stanford and the London School of Economics.
Though an Indian classical music aficionado, he also counts The Beatles' Hey Jude as one of his favourite songs.
Prospect magazine listed him as one of the world's most influential thinkers.
Guha has been, at once, an outspoken critic of Hindu nationalist politics (Narendra Modi's BJP and the right wing) and dynastic politics (the main opposition Congress party led by Rahul Gandhi).
A sought after commentator on TV news, he has kept away from India's rabble-rousing channels.
In the past Hindu right wing groups have demanded an essay on Ramayana by the late poet and scholar AK Ramanujan be dropped from the history syllabus of Delhi University, sent a legal notice to a newspaper for publishing a story on Hindu terrorism and forced a top publisher to recall and destroy copies of a book on Hinduism by a prominent American scholar, Wendy Doniger.
Image copyrightGetty ImagesImage caption Hindu right-wing groups have in the past taken issue with prominent historians No single party in India has a stellar record in defending liberal values.
But many believe that under Mr Modi's government India's reputation as a bastion of liberal values is diminishing by the day.
They say it is a new form of intolerance driven by majoritarian vales, where dissent and criticism is labelled as "anti-national", encouraging a climate of hate and distrust.
This is what is profoundly disturbing about hounding out a scholar from doing his job.





Unlimited Portal Access + Monthly Magazine - 12 issues


Contribute US to Start Broadcasting - It's Voluntary!


ADVERTISE


Merchandise (Peace Series)

 


UN concerned by Taliban's arrest of Afghan women for dress code violations


Pope condemns 'barbarity' of Gaza war as Israeli fire eliminates 85 people queueing for food and brand-new evacuation order released


Pope condemns 'barbarity' of Gaza war as 85 more people are eliminated queueing for food


'They executed him then called his wife to boast': Inside Sweida, the Syrian city wrecked by militias


Letter from Cairo: 'Leaving Gaza was not an escape-- it was an act of desperate survival'


A minimum of 73 Palestinians killed by Israeli shooting while queueing for food aid


Syrian presidency says ceasefire in location, urges parties to respect it


Mary Regan: Coalition must balance jitters over Occupied Territories Bill against its pledges to stand up for what is right


I led US talks for Bill Clinton with Yasser Arafat and Ehud Barak – 25 years on, Israel now has its best chance for lasting peace in Gaza


Syrian forces to go back to Druze location after more violence


Spiritual leaders go to Gaza in wake of fatal church battle


Hundreds more MoD information breaches exposed as security concerns raised in wake of Afghan breach


Pope Francis's priest pal injured as Israelis bomb Gaza's only Catholic church


Syrian president Ahmed al-Sharaa says Israel is trying to fracture Syria with attacks


Syrian government and Druze minority leaders announce a brand-new ceasefire as Israel continues strikes


Benjamin Netanyahu's union federal government suffers significant blow as another party stops


A minimum of 20 Palestinians eliminated at aid circulation website in Gaza


Damascus hit by Israel airstrikes amidst fighting in south of Syria


‘How dare you’ – former minister Alan Shatter criticised in committee on Israeli settlements bill


'Dozens of females and kids' are among 93 killed in Gaza in latest Israeli strikes


Secret UK information breach that put 100,000 Afghans' lives at threat is exposed after super-injunction raised


'How dare you'-- previous minister Alan Shatter criticised in committee on Israeli settlements costs


Israeli strikes in Gaza eliminate 93 Palestinians, health officials say


Former Israeli PM says relocating Gaza civilians could be interpreted as ‘ethnic cleansing’


At least 31 killed in Israeli strikes as fuel scarcity puts medical facilities at danger; no boost in aid regardless of Israel-EU contract


IDF opposes Netanyahu’s plan for Gaza that critics compared to ‘concentration camp’


Israel strikes tanks in Syria after clashes between armed clans


Future of Unifil mission in Lebanon in doubt, but Ireland supports peacekeepers, Tánaiste Simon Harris says


Israel blames ‘technical error’ for deadly drone missile that killed six children in Gaza


Israeli missile hits Gaza children collecting water, IDF blames malfunction


Israel kills six children queuing for water as Gaza death toll tops 58,000; Palestinian-American killed in West Bank


52 Palestinians killed in Israeli airstrikes and shootings near help site in Gaza


Ten kids queuing for food among 16 killed in Israeli strike in Gaza


Michelle L Price: Netanyahu gives Trump something he really wants – a Nobel Peace Prize nomination


Israeli airstrike kills 10 children near Gaza clinic as IDF says it was targeting militant; no immediate truce in sight


Sanctions versus UN attorney over Gaza report denounced


EU agrees deal with Israel to get more food and fuel into Gaza as 10 children die outside clinic


Israel continues bombardment in Gaza amid ceasefire efforts


US issues sanctions against UN investigator probing abuses in Gaza


Hamas states it has agreed to release 10 living hostages as Trump insists ceasefire offer 'really close'